Monday, January 7, 2013

Paper Cuts

You take all of your week's recycling out to the large bins lined up on the curb to be collected by the recycling hauler, and this is your weekly moment of virtue.  You're feeling good knowing that you're doing something good for the environment and reducing the overall amount of trash that goes into landfills, which actually saves the city a lot of money.  It feels good, and you feel good.

The bottles and cans rattle and clang as they hit the bottom of the empty large blue bin.  You're the first person to bring down your load this week.  There are the empty wine bottles from your recent party, so many of them.  You really drank a lot that night (and you were so happy that your wine store had that new Bordeaux on special.  It was so delicious and not very expensive).  Those are the plastic containers from Whole Foods.  Good if not cheap.  This one had the hummus and that one, the dolmades.

And then, there's a whole lot of paper.  Lots and lots of paper.  Paper from the pile on your desk, all of the envelopes from the endless fundraising solicitations.  Paper from the cardboard box your new book came in.  Paper from the newspaper you bought while getting your coffee last Saturday morning (although you're trying to move completely to the e-world with your new iPad).  Paper, paper, paper.

Well, John Schmid, a reporter from the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, joined by a whole team at his newspaper, followed the Wisconsin paper industry and found a familiar trail with some unexpected twists.  The Wisconsin paper industry is collapsing.  It's a story of another Midwestern industry disappearing under the forces of technology and globalization, although in his NPR interview last night (found here), Schmid took pains to point out that his reporting team was trying to avoid that cliche.  His work is called "Paper Cuts" and can be found at Journal Sentinel's online site or by clicking here. 

The digital age is indeed putting pressure on the paper industry, though according to Schmid the industry seemed fairly immune during the first years of the 21st century.  Around 2006, however, that began to change. Schmid notes the irony of the papermill having to work overtime to produce the paper for Walter Isaacson's biography of Steve Jobs, although there is probably no person who did more to move the world to the digital age than Jobs.  That feels to me like building your own coffin or digging your own grave.

And then, of course, there is China.  Once absent from the international paper market, they have emerged in a huge way in recent years.  The Chinese might say that they have re-emerged, since they view paper as one of their cultural patrimonies that they shared with the planet (along with gunpowder and the printing press).  Long thought not to have the wood resources necessary to supply the amount of paper needed by the world's markets, the Chinese have put ingenuity and determination to use, foiling that argument.  They are cross-breeding species of trees that grow to full height in one-tenth the time that a Wisconsin hardwood takes to grow, employing science to solve a problem.

But more telling than their odd and somewhat disturbing experiments with hyper-growing genetically engineered trees is their resourcefulness with something we Americans know a lot about -- waste.

You see, the vast majority of the paper you put into your recycling bin this week, the old envelopes and the cardboard boxes, will be snatched up by China to be reused and returned to the world's paper markets as perfectly serviceable paper products.  There are a number of lessons to take from this parable, but three come to my mind:

  • Of America's defining attributes, one is the ungodly amount of waste that we produce.
  • What we see as waste, China recognizes as value, because China realizes it has a huge amount of use left in it.  
  • America is sitting on a gold mine of wealth in the paper waste it produces, perhaps enough to sustain the Wisconsin paper industry, but we're blind to it, being so focused on Chinese-made plastic objects inside.

My little lessons aren't even the full story. The Sentinel's webpage doesn't let us off that easily.  It tackles the other component in all of this, the carbon question implicit in the paperless, digital world.  "The carbon dioxide emissions produced by running your computer for 23 days are the same as produced by an average American's use of office paper for a full year," it states with unsettling clarity.

Much of this leaves the head in a swirl.  The takeaways are many, but I can't help but focus on what seems to me incontrovertible -- Americans have an incredibly short-sighted view of our future -- a myopia that shapes our definition of what we want and what we need.  The singer Will.i.am referred to it as a "Culture of Now" recently on the BBC.  He is right.  There is a reason that we are out performed by the Chinese in so many spheres of economic activity.  One is the unconscionable amount of waste that we produce.  Another is that our pile of waste has a huge amount of value in it which we will not see.  The collapse of a centuries-old American industry, destroying a regional economy as it goes, gives us yet another chance to pause, look around and see what's staring back at us from the page.

(Not without my own ironic funnybone, I note that I publish this on my online blog.)

Saturday, January 5, 2013

A thought for a Saturday morning

There are some people of whom you might say: They speak with such certitude of what they know, which can only mean that they are wrong. 

Friday, January 4, 2013

Cambridge to ban plastic bags ... soon!

Last night, at the Green Cambridge meeting, I heard that efforts are underway in the Cambridge City Council to ban plastic bags in the city.  Some important details are still to be determined including whether there will be an outright ban on bags or only a fee on them as a disincentive to their continued use, and should this apply to retail establishments of all sizes, or only the larger of them.  Deciding those should only take another two years.

I say this not out of spite.  In my first year on the City Council, I went to a meeting on banning plastic bags where city staff explained all the reasons why a ban didn't make any sense.  That year was 2008.  Five years later, we're only a couple of thorny decisions away from seeing this turn into reality.

As my former colleague Ken Reeves used to remark, the wheels of government do turn slowly.

Friday, December 21, 2012

Friday Grab Bag: The collapse of the nation-state? The return of the city-state?

Today is a Friday, which means it's Grab Bag day.  Here are my two intriguing thoughts for today, thoughts that will remain here as questions in need of answers.  If you've got insights, feel free to chime in:

  1. Have we entered an era where we are witnessing the collapse of the nation-state and the return of the city-state? In the developed world, are New York, Boston, San Francisco, London, Paris, Shanghai more like each other and more like ancient Athens, fortified and yet isolated by economic, political, social and demographic pressures that in effect allow them to make their own foreign policies irrespective of their national political dialogues?  Perhaps it's not just that they are allowed to, but rather that they are forced to.  If these cities are not dependent on the nations that host them but need to interact with labor markets and capital flows from across this globe, where do we go from here?  What does it say about the political divide in the United States where red and blue states seem to be marching in two very different directions at the same time?  Does that rift heal or only grow more intense in this new condition?
  2. When did our sense of architecture include the notion of a disposable building?  Did an American 150 years ago have a very static sense of the future -- life for the next generation will be largely like life is for us now?  Did a European 500 years ago assume that they had reached the pinnacle of human existence?  And, if that notion ever truly existed, that the future would look very much like today, when did it change?  I think it's fair to say that in today's advanced industrialized economies, most would accede to the statement that their lives will be very different 10 years from now.  Technology alone ensures that.  But has this notion of change applied to our buildings as well?  In the 1880s, Cambridge City Hall was designed and built to look like it would be around for a long, long time.  Presumably, that design statement was no accident. Now, buildings go up with an outer skin of glass, conveying a very different feeling about permanence and the role that building will be playing in the future. What are we in fact saying with them?
Ah, random thoughts for a Friday.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Keith Moon, we hardly knew ya

Keith Moon, the erstwhile drummer for the rock group The Who, was famous for flushing explosives down toilets.

Indeed, once in 1967 in Flint Michigan he tried to flush a stick of dynamite down a Holiday Inn bowl.  When the lit dynamite didn't flush, he had the good sense to jump out of the bathroom moments before shards of flying porcelain sprayed the room.

Disappointed that his toilet plan hadn't succeeded exactly as he had hoped, Moon allegedly went downstairs and drove a Cadillac (he later claimed it was a Lincoln Continental) into the hotel pool, causing him to break his tooth.  This account is disputed by others who claim that Moon broke his tooth not by driving a car into a full swimming pool but by diving into an empty one.

As a boy, Moon was sent to the Alperton Secondary Modern School after failing his eleven plus exam at his prior school.  At Alperton, a teacher assessed the future rock drummer this way: "Retarded artistically.  Idiotic in other respects."  I kid you not.

Keith Moon died of a drug overdose in London on September 7, 1978, having dined out earlier that evening with Paul and Linda McCartney.  He was 32 years old.

Saturday, December 15, 2012

This tragedy, the horrific violence

Looking in the mirror is a humbling thing this eve.  All 46 years of breathing self look back at me.  In light of all the very small children killed in two Connecticut classrooms on Friday, this is hard.

These little lives were on the road to life. 

Of the many photographs of the horror, I gravitated toward this one -- the boy, hands half-covering his face with shock in his eyes, his older sister caring and comforting him with her arm around him while she herself looks intently at the ground.  This was every younger brother and older sister.   See it in them, courage, care, concern, fear and shock.  Not comprehending the incomprehensible is not a sin.  But a child would not know this.  Obama is right.  Our hearts are broken.

The political points are as obvious to me as they are maddening.  To those who say "Guns don't kill people, people kill people", the correct response is "People with guns kill people."  And they continue to.  Even children.  To this day.  Many children.

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Strange memories from 93rd Street

When I was a young boy, I lived with my mother and my sister on East 93rd Street in Manhattan.  We had a dog, a Gordon Setter.  Like many setters, he was wire thin when he was young.  Concentration camp thin. Gordons are black with brown spots and also like a lot of setters, he was nervous.  Some might call it alert, but others would certainly call it neurotic. 

That was, of course, before he ballooned out in later years.  Imagine a straight piece of uncooked spaghetti transforming into a basketball over the span of a decade.  And then there were the ticks.  But I'm losing the thread of my story. 

My mother once said to me that she'd wished she'd been a little more adventurous with his name.  She'd wanted to call him Glenraven Ballachulish, which is actually a place name in Scotland.  When I told a school friend about this years later, he just laughed.

The dog had a name: Nat.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Networks and proximity.

Did you ever think about how beguilingly simple LinkedIn is? It follows the basic rubric that every 4th grader knows -- we're friends, and he's a friend of yours, so in a sense your friend becomes my friend too.  Facebook isn't different in nature, in fact it even grabbed the word "friend" creating along the way the new English participle "friending".  But Facebook is less explicit in the value it assigns to the links that build the network of friends. With Facebook the goal is to have the platform to express yourself to an audience, whereas with LinkedIn, in some senses the goal is the network itself.

Now, look at your LinkedIn network.  How many of them are in the same city as you?  Indeed, going through your connections and mapping them spatially, would the greatest amount of activity, the greatest amount of connectivity, appear closest to where you physically are?  Why is that?  What role does proximity play in the creation of a social network? 

This question was being swatted back and forth by me and Quinton Zondervan like a ping pong ball over a net stretched across two coffee cups.  Its related question -- what role does proximity play in the capacity of a social network to expand? -- was the real object of our desire, the true set point we sought, but it seemed impossible to answer the second one without first getting a handle on the first. 

Suffice it to say that Quinton and I both assume that proximity in the relational tie increases the strength of the relational tie and that the strength of the connection diminishes as distance increases.  In other words, closer is stronger.

How and why this is relevant comes clearer in an example from the real-world of urban development.  There is much talk, presumably accurate and measurable, of the importance of MIT to the development of Kendall Square.  In my imagining, this means that social networks get created at the university and then expand into the neighboring area of Kendall Square, like little arms of energy shooting out from the main orb (for some reason, I can't help but think of this like some cartooney depiction of a solar flare - at least what my mind imagines a cartoon of a solar flare to look like).  These little explosions of energy seed an environment that is highly creative and highly innovative.  It is the Ur-situation, much like those Walt Disney cartoon movies from the 1940s where the lightening bolt strikes the muck and mire of a swampy marsh on prehistoric earth and a single-celled organism springs to life.

Now, let's fast forward this eco-experiment a generation (roughly equivalent to 30 years).  With innovation flourishing there exists a high degree of bio-diversity in this innovation ecosystem.  Unfortunately, it means that the bigger predators recognize a food source, and they start lumbering our way.  Say a Microsoft decides to locate in Kendall Square, to tap into the tremendous talent pool that exists here.  Or a Google.  Or a Novartis.  In these instances, they are trying to appropriate the entire network already developed at MIT, lock stock and barrel.  They are not interested in fostering innovation.  They are interested in capturing the entirety of it and they will use their gullet to digest it whole.  Innovation decreases as mono-cultures replace the highly complex and diverse environments that precede them.